Court Says Social Media Sites Off Limits to Sex Offenders

A New Jersey appellate court has upheld the state parole board’s restriction disallowing convicted sex offenders from accessing social media or other comparable web sites.

Superior Court Judge,  Jack Sabatino, writing for the three judge panel, said, “we are satisfied that the Internet restrictions adopted here by the Parole Board have been constitutionally tailored to attempt to strike a fair balance.”  Judge Sabatino continued, “We recognize that websites such as Facebook and LinkedIn have developed a variety of uses apart from interactive communications with third parties.  Even so, the Parole Board has reasonably attempted to draw the line of permitted access in a fair manner that balances the important public safety interests at stake with the offenders’ interests in free expression and association.”

The defendants, several convicted sexual offenders whose cases were consolidated, challenged the constitutionality of the restrictions as infringing their First Amendment rights of free speech and association, a violation of their Due Process rights and  corresponding rights under New Jersey’s Constitution.  The restrictions stem from Megan’s Law, which is a series of laws, originally passed in New Jersey, aimed at sex offenders.  One component of Megan’s law includes a requirement that those persons convicted between 1994 and 2004 of certain sexual offenses must serve, in addition to any existing sentence, a special sentence of  “community supervision for life,” and those convicted after that date range are sentenced to “parole supervision for life.”

The New Jersey Parole Board’s restriction does provide for parolees to seek special permission for gaining access to certain sites for work or another “reasonable purpose.”  The state’s Deputy Attorney General said, “It is not the Parole Board’s intention that these provisions bar appellants from having Internet access to news, entertainment, and commercial transactions.”

The New Jersey restriction is hardly novel as these cases have been sprouting up throughout the nation with varied outcomes.  You can read the full opinion here.